How to read the cases
The following cases are wholly fictional teaching examples, not disguised patient records, trial participants, or promises about outcomes. Each includes a working hypothesis, competing explanations, a provisional decision, and evidence that would change the plan. The shorter formulations omit numerical ratings to keep attention on treatment-planning decisions. The extended workplace walkthrough includes illustrative assessment ratings to show how a completed target record can look; those numbers are fictional, not expected scores or evidence of an actual outcome.
The formulations are not complete clinical assessments. In practice, a clinician would establish diagnosis, risk, competence, consent, and the appropriate treatment pathway before applying them. The cases show why “finding the target” sometimes leads to a memory, sometimes to further assessment, and sometimes to deciding not to process a memory at that point.
Case One Marcus and the alarm at the end of the shift
Returning to the fictional Marcus introduced in Chapter 20, this expanded formulation shows how the same candidate target fits within coordinated care.
Presenting problem and desired change. Marcus, 41, works in building maintenance. Eighteen months after a workplace assault, he reports intrusive recollections, nightmares, avoidance of one corridor, and marked alarm when doors close behind him. A competent assessment supports PTSD. He also has an assessed alcohol-use disorder. His priorities are to finish shifts without leaving early, sleep more reliably, and reduce the drinking that has begun to damage his relationship and work attendance.
Context and immediate assessment. The perpetrator no longer works at the site, and the employer has changed access arrangements. The clinician nevertheless checks whether any continuing threat remains. Marcus has reliable housing and wants his partner involved in limited aspects of planning, but not in the content of his trauma sessions. He is receiving addiction care. The team clarifies who assesses withdrawal risk, manages relevant medication, and responds to a deterioration in drinking or safety. No claim is made that psychotherapy alone makes alcohol withdrawal safe.
Recent episode. A closing alarm sounds at 6 p.m. Marcus sees an image of the attacker's hand on the door. His chest tightens, he thinks “I cannot get out,” and he leaves through a side exit. At home, alcohol reduces his immediate distress. Later, sleep is poor and he feels ashamed. He sometimes drinks on days without the alarm, including social occasions, which shows that the trauma cue is not the only maintaining factor.
Working formulation. A remembered moment of blocked escape appears to contribute to cue-triggered re-experiencing and avoidance. Drinking sometimes functions to dampen that response but also has other reinforcement and dependence-related features. The plan therefore does not equate PTSD improvement with recovery from alcohol-use disorder.
Competing explanations. The team considers panic processes, occupational stress, sleep disruption, and substance-related effects. The chest symptoms receive appropriate medical consideration. If episodes occur without trauma cues and are maintained by fear of bodily catastrophe, panic-specific assessment may become necessary. If the workplace remains objectively unsafe, environmental action takes priority over construing all alarm as a memory effect.
Assessment Script: “The door image seems central when the closing alarm sounds. Is that the moment you want to work on, or is there another part that matters more? On evenings when you drink without that image, what is happening? What would tell us the trauma work is helping even if the alcohol problem still needs its own care?”
Candidate target and rationale. Marcus selects the remembered moment when the attacker blocked the exit. The rationale is its direct relationship to the present alarm and work avoidance. It is not chosen because it is the worst event in his life. A childhood experience of being trapped is noted but not prioritized solely because it is earlier; Marcus does not currently experience it as part of the same problem.
Readiness and coordinated plan. PTSD treatment is considered alongside substance-use treatment rather than being withheld until an arbitrary period of abstinence has elapsed. This is consistent with guidance supporting access to trauma-focused PTSD therapy in people with co-occurring substance-use disorders. [32] The team establishes session-specific feasibility, a practical between-session plan, and communication boundaries with Marcus's consent. Intoxication or medically concerning withdrawal would change the immediate action, not create a permanent prohibition.
Past–present–future sequence. The past focus is the blocked exit. The present focus is the closing alarm and the corridor. The future aim is to finish a shift, notice the difference between a reminder and actual danger, use agreed coping and support, and travel home according to his care plan. A future rehearsal includes what he will do if distress remains high; it does not imagine guaranteed comfort.
Reevaluation and decision branch. In a hypothetical review, Marcus reports that the door image is less intrusive and that he finishes more shifts, but weekend drinking is unchanged. The appropriate inference is partial improvement in the hypothesized trauma pathway, not a completed recovery or a failed EMDR course. Addiction treatment continues. If work avoidance remains, the clinician examines its current function instead of automatically selecting another memory.
Consultation questions. Is the PTSD indication adequately established? Is the target linked to the specific impairment? Are medical and addiction responsibilities explicit? What evidence would distinguish residual PTSD from an independent alcohol-use process? Has the client been offered genuine treatment choices rather than a promise that processing will solve everything?
Case Two Imani and the question of whether the danger is over
Presenting problem and desired change. Imani, 35, asks for EMDR because she feels “obsessed” with whether her partner is lying. She describes repeated checking of messages, poor sleep, and distress after discovering an affair. Her initial goal is to stop feeling anxious so the relationship can return to normal. A private assessment reveals that her partner also threatens to disclose personal information, controls access to shared money, and monitors her travel.
Why the initial request is not the whole formulation. The word “obsessed” does not establish OCD, and betrayal does not automatically establish PTSD. The clinician assesses trauma exposure and symptom patterns without presuming either diagnosis. Some checking may be driven by intolerable uncertainty, some by repeated deception, and some by attempts to anticipate a controlling partner's behavior. Reducing all checking without understanding these functions could remove an improvised protective strategy while leaving the threat intact.
Immediate priorities. The clinician explores privacy, safe communication, access to money and support, and whether appointments or written records could increase risk. Imani is offered specialist domestic-abuse resources and practical options without pressure to leave on a timetable chosen by the therapist. WHO's guidance emphasizes autonomy, supportive first-line response, and safety in care for women experiencing violence. [29] Local legal and safeguarding responsibilities are checked separately.
Working formulation. Current coercion and uncertainty are major maintaining conditions. A remembered episode of discovering the affair is distressing, but processing it would not make the present relationship safe. Imani also recalls a former partner disappearing without explanation. This may be relevant to the intensity of abandonment fear; it does not explain away her current partner's behavior.
Assessment Script: “Some of what you describe may be an old alarm, and some may be information about what is happening now. What do you fear your partner would do if you disagreed or changed your plans? Is there a safe way for us to contact you? Would you like to consider support options before deciding whether memory work belongs in the plan?”
Candidate targets and the decision not to start. The affair discovery and the earlier disappearance are recorded as possible future topics, not an immediate processing queue. The clinician does not select “I am too needy” as the negative cognition simply because Imani uses that phrase after arguments. Its source and function need examination; it may repeat the partner's demeaning account. At this point, the active focus is safety, informed choice, support, and a clearer differential formulation.
What would justify reconsideration. Later memory-focused work might become appropriate if Imani wishes it, an appropriate indication and evidence discussion are established, and the delivery context is workable. Complete absence of every life stressor is not required. However, active danger must remain represented in the plan, and reducing alarm must never be used to imply that a threat has become acceptable.
Past–present–future map. Past: known episodes of betrayal or unexplained separation that remain distressing. Present: actual threats, monitoring, uncertainty, and checking. Future: recognizing options, contacting support safely, setting boundaries where feasible, and responding to uncertainty without abandoning self-protection. A future template would not require imagining reconciliation or trusting the current partner.
Future Planning Script: “Imagine a situation in which you notice pressure to agree to something you do not want. What would help you recognize your options? Which response is safe in that setting? If speaking directly would increase danger, what other route to support could you use?” The answer may involve postponing a conversation or seeking practical assistance rather than assertiveness in the moment.
Reevaluation and decision branch. In one hypothetical development, Imani gains access to independent advice and chooses a separation. Her anxiety initially increases because the transition brings genuine uncertainty. That increase is not proof that she chose wrongly or that processing should be accelerated. The plan updates the safety assessment and support needs. If, later, a remembered scene continues to drive impairment in a safer context, target selection can be revisited with a more accurate purpose.
Consultation questions. Has the clinician privately assessed coercion? Is a memory explanation obscuring current conduct? Would any proposed couple intervention be safe and freely chosen? Are records and contact methods safe? Is success being defined by Imani's agency and functioning rather than the survival of the relationship?
Case Three Noor and the medical waiting room
Presenting problem and desired change. Noor, 26, is autistic and communicates fluently but needs time to process unexpected questions. After a frightening emergency procedure, Noor avoids medical appointments and experiences intrusive images of being held still. The initial referral describes “noncompliance.” Noor describes a different goal: “I want to get healthcare without feeling trapped, and I need staff to explain before touching me.” Assessment explores PTSD, the exact circumstances of the procedure, and current healthcare needs.
Access and environmental assessment. Bright lights, crowded rooms, unpredictable waiting, and rapid questioning are difficult even when no traumatic memory is present. The clinician distinguishes longstanding sensory needs from new trauma-related responses. Accommodations are not made conditional on successful therapy. Noor chooses written agendas, clear explanations, pauses before answering, and a non-touch form of the agreed intervention where clinically appropriate.
Recent episode. A nurse reaches toward Noor without warning. Noor experiences a sharp image of the emergency room, loses track of the question, and leaves. In a quieter appointment where each step is explained, anxiety is lower but the image still appears when equipment is placed nearby. This pattern suggests both a memory-linked process and continuing access barriers.
Working formulation. A known medical event may contribute to re-experiencing and avoidance. Sensory overload and lack of predictable consent procedures independently increase distress. Therapy should address the trauma-related component while the healthcare team improves accessibility. The objective is not to make Noor tolerate unnecessary touch or behave less autistically.
Assessment Script: “Which part is the memory coming back, and which part is difficult because of what the room or staff are doing now? You can answer in writing or take time. When you say you lose track, do you mean the question becomes hard to follow, you feel far away, or there is a period you cannot remember?”
Dissociation and competing explanations. Noor reports two episodes of feeling unreal but no established recurrent amnesia. The clinician does not infer a dissociative disorder from autistic shutdown or a single description. Further assessment considers panic, overload, fatigue, medication effects, and dissociative symptoms. If substantial unexplained gaps or loss of orientation emerge, specialist consultation is obtained before progressing with a memory-processing plan.
Candidate target and rationale. Noor identifies a remembered moment of being held still after saying “wait.” The current meaning is “My no does not count.” The target is not “hospitals” as a whole or a therapist-invented scene of earlier abuse. It fits because it recurs at present appointments and relates directly to Noor's desired ability to receive care with agency.
Evidence and consent. The clinician explains the evidence for EMDR in PTSD while acknowledging that evidence about specific autism adaptations is less developed. Therapist consensus on adaptations can inform accessibility but cannot guarantee efficacy. [37] Noor is offered alternatives and may decline EMDR without losing support for healthcare access.
Readiness and plan. Before proceeding, the clinician checks that Noor understands the task, can signal a pause in a usable way, and can remain sufficiently aware of the current setting. Apparent stillness is not assumed to mean comfort. The clinician also confirms a plan for upcoming medically necessary appointments so that therapy does not inadvertently delay essential care.
Past–present–future map. Past: the known restraint-related moment. Present: unannounced approaches, equipment, and waiting-room cues. Future: attending an appointment with written preferences, asking for an explanation, using a pause signal, and deciding with staff how to continue. The future scenario includes a staff member forgetting the plan and Noor using an agreed route for clarification or support; it does not assume a perfect healthcare system.
Reevaluation and decision branch. In a hypothetical review, Noor reports fewer intrusive images but still needs reduced sensory load and extra processing time. Those ongoing needs are not treatment failure. If the image improves while avoidance persists, the clinician assesses whether the remaining barrier is sensory, practical, relational, or trauma-related. If dissociation increases, the plan pauses for assessment rather than pushing harder through the same target.
Consultation questions. Are autism-related needs being mistaken for resistance or symptoms to eliminate? Is the target a known event rather than an inferred cause? Have trauma and environmental barriers been separately measured? What would establish that an adaptation preserves meaningful consent and participation? Is specialist input needed for unresolved diagnostic or dissociative questions?
Case Four: a complete practical route through workplace performance
This fictional walkthrough uses the twelve-part format of the condition chapters. It compresses a course of work, not a promised single-session result. Chapters 11 and 12 provide further performance and evaluation-anxiety examples.
1. Clinical focus
Clinical focus: Help Tess stay engaged when presenting her work, including when she makes a mistake. The job is not to guarantee praise or remove every normal performance sensation. Tess, an analyst, knows the material but repeatedly hands her monthly report to a colleague when she loses her place.
2. What the client says
“I know the answer until everyone looks at me.” “If I stumble, I become the joke.” “I want to finish my own report instead of escaping.” These statements suggest an assessment of performance episodes and shame, not an automatic PTSD diagnosis.
3. Likely past, present, and future targets
Past: Tess recalls classmates laughing during a school presentation. Recent episode: losing her place in last month's report. Present trigger: opening the slide deck while colleagues turn toward her. Future: presenting next month's report and handling a question she cannot immediately answer. Only the first two are remembered events; the anticipated report is an imagined future situation. Assessment also checks whether current colleagues are actually mistreating her.
4. Choosing where to begin
Assessment Script: “Which of these moments seems most connected with what happens when you stand up now?” Tess identifies the classroom scene and says it brings the same heat and wish to disappear. They choose that known memory within the treatment plan. The therapist records her connection rather than declaring that school caused all workplace anxiety. A different client's recent workplace incident could be the better starting point.
5. Brief, specific preparation
The therapist explains the process and invites correction, practices Tess's stop signal, checks that she can notice both memory and present setting, and agrees on closure and between-session support. Tess says she tends to hide difficulty to appear competent, so they explicitly agree that saying “this is not helping” is useful information. Presentation practice remains part of the plan; memory processing does not replace learning the actual task.
6. Completed assessment
- Selected event and image: the school presentation; looking up at laughing faces after losing her place.
- Client's negative cognition: “I am ridiculous.”
- Preferred positive cognition: “I can handle a mistake.”
- Felt validity: 2 on the 1–7 VoC scale.
- Emotions and disturbance: shame, sadness, fear; SUD 7 on a 0–10 scale.
- Body: heat in her face and tightness across her chest.
These are illustrative ratings, not expected scores. The therapist elicits the components rather than showing Tess a completed answer sheet. “I can handle a mistake” is her desired adaptive response; “Everyone will approve” would make the goal depend on controlling other people.
7. Illustrative processing with reasoning
Therapist says: “Bring up that image, the words ‘I am ridiculous,’ and where you notice it in your body.” Next step: After the agreed target activation, the clinician uses the bilateral stimulation and procedures of their training, then asks, “What do you notice now?”
Client response: “I want to hide my face.” Clinical reasoning: The response is an association to follow, not a cue to reassure her that nobody noticed. Therapist says: “Notice that.” Next step: Continue according to the trained protocol while monitoring engagement.
Client response after further work: “Now I'm angry. The teacher just stood there.” Clinical reasoning: Anger is a change in the material, not automatically a blockage or worsening. Therapist says: “Go with that.” The therapist does not supply an interpretation about the teacher's intentions.
Client response later: “I was a kid trying to do something hard.” Clinical reasoning: This is Tess's emerging perspective. There is no need to turn it into a lecture or repeat a prepared interweave. Next step: Allow processing to continue, then return to the original target at the appropriate point in the protocol and assess what remains.
The clinician's reasoning appears here for the reader; it would not be spoken after every client response. These exchanges omit many possible sets and pauses. No particular sequence of anger, sadness, or insight is required for effective work.
8. If the session takes another turn
If Tess says, “Tell me I'm not ridiculous,” the therapist notices the relational need without repeatedly proving the belief false: “What happens inside as you ask me that?” If she is simply seeking clarification or support, respond to that need; do not label every question avoidance. If the same material loops, reassess the blockage and consider an appropriately timed intervention within training. If an earlier memory appears, follow relevant associations and document it without claiming it is the original cause. If Tess becomes disconnected, pause target work and restore present contact before making a next decision.
9. Completion or incomplete closure
If sufficiently processed: Tess returns to the classroom image and reports that it no longer carries the earlier shame response. The clinician checks residual disturbance rather than treating one positive statement as completion, reassesses the positive cognition that fits now, and proceeds with installation and body scan according to the protocol. Any meaningful residual disturbance is addressed, not concealed to produce a clean ending.
If unfinished: suppose chest tightness and shame remain when closure time arrives. The therapist records the active aspect, ends processing, helps Tess orient and use the agreed supports, and plans reevaluation. They do not force installation or rehearse the distressing scene alone as homework. Closure includes checking her state, the transition out of the appointment, what to note between visits, and how to obtain appropriate support if difficulties escalate.
10. Present trigger and future template
At a later review, the classroom scene is less disturbing but opening the slide deck still brings a jolt. The therapist assesses that present trigger rather than announcing treatment finished. Once relevant processing and skills work support it, Tess rehearses opening the deck, giving the first sentence, pausing when interrupted, finding her place, and finishing. The scene includes a minor correction and a question she cannot answer: “I will check that and follow up.” If rehearsal stalls, they identify the point of difficulty and determine whether it calls for more assessment, processing, or practice.
11. Reevaluation and next steps
Reevaluation Script: “What do you notice with the classroom memory now? What happened when you opened the deck? Were you able to finish your report, and what did you do when nerves rose?” A completed presentation with some anxiety may be a meaningful gain. No presentation opportunity means generalization remains untested. Continued avoidance prompts assessment of residual shame, present workplace conditions, missing skills, or another maintaining process—not a presumption that Tess failed or must have a hidden trauma.
12. Quick reference
Target: a specific client-identified humiliation memory. Meaning: “I am ridiculous.” Adaptive direction: “I can handle a mistake.” Processing: follow her associations, not a prewritten emotional arc. Branch: assess looping, disconnection, current mistreatment, or skill gaps. Closure: distinguish resolved target work from unfinished work. Future action: present, recover from a mistake, and continue. Outcome: participation and recovery, not universal approval.
The common reasoning across different decisions
These cases lead to different immediate actions because their formulations differ. Marcus may receive coordinated PTSD and substance-use treatment. Imani needs a plan that foregrounds current coercion before assuming memory processing is the next step. Noor may need both trauma treatment and enduring accessibility changes, with specialist input if assessment identifies additional complexity. Tess illustrates a memory-focused plan for performance difficulties, followed by present-trigger assessment, practical rehearsal, and review of functioning.
A coherent target is not the most emotionally dramatic detail in the history. It is a justified, collaborative treatment focus whose relationship to the person's goals can be examined. Consultation is most useful when the clinician brings that reasoning—including uncertainty—rather than only asking which memory should come first.
